Talk:Good Quality Applications Built With Delphi
From Delphi Programming
Contents |
[edit] Open Source
- I recommend moving the Open Source projects out of this page into their own page. Being "open source" doesn't automatically make it "Good Quality" :) Eddie 14:52, 26 January 2007 (UTC)
- Like the other application lists, the "Open Source" list should not list every single open source application but only the better ones. So I do not see the need to move it and I would suggest to keep in on the page. I am not worried that the page becomes too long, after all there are many good applications written in Delphi and this page should reflect this. Only the hi-profile list representing the top applications needs to be trimmed from time to time, otherwise too many people try to self promote in that list. --Rif 17:20, 28 January 2007 (UTC)
- Would it be worth creating a new page as a place for all open source projects to be listed? Naturally, only people who make the effort to add their open source projects would add to the list. Eddie 18:51, 28 January 2007 (UTC)
- Neither does being "open source" automatically make it not "Good Quality". Keep it about quality, not about license. 88.159.74.100 17:40, 3 June 2007 (UTC)
- Like the other application lists, the "Open Source" list should not list every single open source application but only the better ones. So I do not see the need to move it and I would suggest to keep in on the page. I am not worried that the page becomes too long, after all there are many good applications written in Delphi and this page should reflect this. Only the hi-profile list representing the top applications needs to be trimmed from time to time, otherwise too many people try to self promote in that list. --Rif 17:20, 28 January 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Hi-Profile List
Afaik Skype btw migrated to the C++ branch on all platforms? IOW afaik currently Skype/win32 is not Delphi-built anymore. 88.159.74.100 17:42, 3 June 2007 (UTC)
- Skype (version 3.2) for Win32 is made in Delphi. However Joost the TV distribution is not a Delphi application. --Rif 04:19, 4 June 2007 (UTC)
- Demote!
- There is an absurd amount of obscure applications in the "hi profile" list. Who has ever heard of "Punto de Ventas"? I speak spanish, and I've never heard of such application. Here's my quick candidate list to be put on the "lesser known" list:
| 23th September 2008 | ConnectedText |
| 29th August 2008 | Dilmanc MT System |
| 5th August 2008 | Punto de Ventas |
| 23rd July 2008 | Open Contacts |
| 5th July 2008 | jv16 PowerTools |
| 29th June 2008 | PL/SQL Developer |
| 17th March 2008 | ColorImpact |
| 12th September 2007 | VersePerfect |
| 9th August 2007 | IDRISI |
| 12th January 2007 | Altium Designer |
| 9th March 2006 | e/pop web conferencing |
| 15th March 2005 | Installaware |
| 10th January 2005 | Ultra Fractal |
| 6th January 2005 | Exchequer Enterprise |
| 5th January 2005 | Multilizer |
| 5th January 2005 | IBP |
Leus 21:41, 25 September 2008 (UTC)
- At least InstallAware is known to everybody who uses Delphi 2005 up. But not really for good reasons, because it was a major pain in the lower back until recently. I haven't heard of the others either, but that does not mean they cannot be famous in some niche market. --Dummzeuch 06:21, 26 September 2008 (UTC)
- And that's my point... niche markets doesn't qualify as "hi profile," IMHO. --Leus 14:42, 26 September 2008 (UTC)
- Niche market could mean e.g. that all stockbrokers of the world use a program, but nobody else has heard about it. Or, another example: The company I work for, has a program called Stradivari, which is used to display pictures taken during road surveys. Nobody but our customers probably knows this program, but it is pretty much the only one for that job, so for some people it is high profile.--Dummzeuch 18:53, 26 September 2008 (UTC)
- See? That's precisely a low profile application, one that only what, a thousand people in the whole world, maybe? have ever heard of. --Leus 14:13, 3 October 2008 (UTC)
- Niche market could mean e.g. that all stockbrokers of the world use a program, but nobody else has heard about it. Or, another example: The company I work for, has a program called Stradivari, which is used to display pictures taken during road surveys. Nobody but our customers probably knows this program, but it is pretty much the only one for that job, so for some people it is high profile.--Dummzeuch 18:53, 26 September 2008 (UTC)
- And that's my point... niche markets doesn't qualify as "hi profile," IMHO. --Leus 14:42, 26 September 2008 (UTC)
- Yes you are right the hi-profile list is getting overloaded. Some people are a bit over-optimistic when they add in applications - about where they should go. From time to time I do a purge to clean up, I will do so in a few days. However note that hi-profile is not just to show mass market applications, but also outstanding applications in somewhat more narrow market are considered e.g. Altrium Designer is excellent as electronics hardware development, but certainly not a typical business office application.--Rif 11:45, 27 September 2008 (UTC)
- Then I misunderstand what "high profile" means, which, accordingly to the American Heritage Dictionary, is An intentionally conspicuous, well-publicized presence or stance. To me, "high profile" means that it is well known, not necessarily an indicator of quality. --Leus 14:13, 3 October 2008 (UTC)
- At least InstallAware is known to everybody who uses Delphi 2005 up. But not really for good reasons, because it was a major pain in the lower back until recently. I haven't heard of the others either, but that does not mean they cannot be famous in some niche market. --Dummzeuch 06:21, 26 September 2008 (UTC)
[edit] Delphi Versions
I suggest to add the list with a column "Delphi Version". A lot of people want to know wich Delphi Version is used (D3, D5, D7 ...)
- As new Delphi versions are released many programs listed would over time using these newer version. It gets too complecated to track these kind of changes. I rather want the effort spend on adding more programs to the list. --Rif 08:13, 26 May 2007 (UTC)
[edit] Older Comments
What is the criteria for inclusion in "Hi-Profile" list?
For example I made a small check and most of my co-workers never heard of following "hi-profile" applications: Total Commander RegexBuddy TimeLeft WiredRed Upscene Database Workbench Pro Numara Track-It! AquaSoft DiaShow XP five ISYS Search VVVV TuneUp Utilities SpamBully Ultra Fractal Exchequer Enterprise eEmpACT IBP Font Creator Program
At the same time they knew following "lesser known" applications: Free Split FuturixImager EMS SQL Manager WinHex Xnews PE Explorer ASPack DeepBurner Netcaptor Hot Dog
I suggest for the list to be sorted again.
- The hi-profile list is groomed from time to time, to avoid that it becomes overweight and messy. --Rif 08:13, 26 May 2007 (UTC)
